I think “myth” is too polite a term here. Complete and utter bullshit would seem to be more appropriate, both for the situation in Canada, and in the United States.
On the one hand, there is constant whining on the part or the tech industry that they cannot find enough qualified people. Their solution: allow in more immigrants who, while qualified, will often work for less money in order to get here and get established. This is, in effect, absolutely no different than off-shoring the jobs in order to get them done more cheaply. Whether they hire people off-shore, or bring people from off-shore here, it amounts to the same thing.
On the other hand, we have stories like this one on age discrimination, this one Companies won’t even look at resumes of the long-term unemployed. Then there are the many, many articles regarding the challenges of new grads finding work in their fields, including many in STEM fields.
So lets look at these points:
- Tech companies claim they cannot find qualified staff;
- These same companies do not hire new grads because they “lack experience”;
- These same companies will not look at long-term unemployed (assuming 6 months is “long term”), because there must be something wrong with them, or because all of their skills have become obsolete in 6 months;
- These same companies do want to hire over 50s because their skills much be out-of-date
Does anyone else see the bullshit in this situation? The reality is that
- Companies want experience, but they do not want to pay for it.
- Companies can get experience for less by importing it, because many people want to come to North America.
- Companies are not interested in investing in building the experience base by hiring the inexperienced and growing them.
I have worked for many companies that did hire new grads, did invest in growing that talent, and did hire experienced people (even though they were more expensive) to mentor that junior staff. And you know what, those companies were successful.
Do not get me wrong, I am not “anti-immigration”. I think that immigration adds a great deal to our country.
Just don’t try to feed me some bullshit line that it is the only way to get the technical talent you need.
- What High Tech Skills Shortage? New Study Casts Doubt on Tech Industry Claim (techpresident.com)
- A Tech Worker Shortage in the US? Think Again (cnbc.com)
- VCs and Startups Call for More H-1B Visas, But Some Say Talent Shortage is Exaggerated (pehub.com)
- New Study Suggests No Shortage of American STEM Graduates (Slashdot) (science.slashdot.org)
- “The Skills Gap”: Glut and Shortage at the Same Time (marketfailure.wordpress.com)